Credit Cards - Belgium
HEADLINES
- 7% growth in card volume from 2009 to reach 1.2 million
cards in 2010
- 2% transaction volume and 5% current value growth from
2009 to reach 25 million transactions and €2.8 billion in 2010
- Reduced and more cautious spending and consumers’
reduction of debts hinder credit cards in 2010
- Average transaction spend grows by 3% from 2009 to
reach €169 in 2010
- Citigroup Inc leads card volume with 26% value share in
2009, while BNP Paribas Fortis leads transaction value with 22% share
- 8% card volume and transaction volume CAGR and 7%
constant value CAGR expected for forecast period
TRENDS
- With around 1.2 million cards in 2010, the volume of
credit cards remains much smaller in comparison with that of charge cards.
Credit cards took longer to develop in Belgium in comparison to debit
cards, due to a strong consumer preference for lower-risk charge cards.
Credit cards were also more affected than debit cards by the recession,
which led to the tightening of credit criteria and also to consumer
reluctance to take on more debt. Thanks to earlier highly dynamic growth,
credit cards’ performance over the review period as a whole was however
strong with card volume increasing by 140%, transaction volume by 112% and
current value payments by 87%.
- Personal credit cards were particularly badly affected
by the decline in consumer economic confidence caused by the recession.
Transaction volume rose by only 1% in 2010 over the previous year while
current value sales saw a modest 5% growth. This represents an improvement
on 2009, however, when current value declined by 7%. Low growth in 2010
was due to a general reduction in spending and partly due to the increased
use of charge cards. Average spend per transaction increased to €95 in
2010 from €91 in 2009, however, while remaining below the levels seen
earlier in the review period. This was partly due to spending by
higher-income groups accounting for a larger share of total transaction
volume due to the greater impact of the recession on low- and mid-income
consumers.
- The issuing of credit cards was affected by more
stringent criteria due to amendments to the Belgian Consumer Credit Law in
2009 and the new European Consumer Credit Directive, which will be fully
enforced in January 2011. Whilst imposing more control on credit, the
government however also reduced APR rates in 2009, making the use of
credit cards cheaper. APR rates were reduced to 15% on amounts below
€1,250, 13% on sums of €1,250-5,000 and 12% on sums above €5,000. Lower
APR rates in particular benefited people with credit cards issued by
retail chains, forcing the latter to reduce their charges as they tended
to be above average rates.
- E-commerce remains a strong driver for credit cards,
which are often used to pay for clothes and other personal products and
electronics online. Other growth areas for credit cards include transport
and leisure and recreation, loan consolidation and household goods and
services. Home renovation emerged as one of the most dynamic areas towards
the end of the review period, with many Belgian households opting to
renovate their homes while waiting for property sales and prices to
improve.
- Commercial credit cards remains fairly small but grew
rapidly for most of the decade, driven to a large extent by widening
penetration among small and mid-sized companies. Commercial credit cards
accounted for 35% of card volume but only 21% of transaction volume and
32% of transaction value in 2010. Commercial credit cards however proved
more resilient to the recession in 2010, posting 6% transaction volume and
current value growth over the previous year. Growing usage among small and
mid-sized companies meanwhile reduced average transaction value for
commercial credit cards from €199 in 2005 to €169 in 2010.
- Commercial credit cards attract businesses and
cardholders by offering detailed card reporting and insurance and merchant
discounts. Travel- or accommodation-focused cards became a major point of
competition, with all leading brands offering centralised reporting by the
end of the review period. Private cards linked to corporate credit card
accounts are also increasingly offered as an extra bonus for existing
users and used to attract new clients.
- The usage of personal cards is higher in fashion
outlets and in particular for clothes retail than in retail as a whole.
According to Atos Worldline, credit card payments in fashion stores
increased by 30% in transaction volume and 43% in current value terms from
2005 to 2009. People paying with credit cards for clothes, footwear and
leather goods also spent on average more than on retail purchases in
general at €158 in 2009.
COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE
- Since 2009, credit card issuers had to follow new
regulations that aim to protect consumers against the unethical marketing
of credit cards. The new Law on Consumer Credit requires banks to issue
credit cards only to bona fide customers. During the review period, the
credit industry was criticised as contributing to the growing indebtedness
of Belgian households through irresponsible lending. By the end of the
review period, Belgian banks thus promoted credit cards more discretely
via branch offices and merchants. Only Citigroup and ING openly promoted
revolving credit cards on their websites towards the end of the review
period.
- Citigroup Inc and BNP Paribas Personal Finance, via its
subsidiary Cetelem, were the most dynamic and leading issuers of personal
credit cards in 2009, increasing their card volume share by about a
percentage point each over the previous year. Citigroup Inc made a
determined drive towards the end of the review period to position itself
as the main issuer of personal credit cards among the banks, which pushed
its transaction value share to 25% in 2009, up from 22% in 2008. However,
the bank’s transaction value share of commercial credit cards declined due
to its sale of Diners Club to Discover Financial Services in 2008.
- BCC Corporate and the leading banks are the main
issuers of commercial credit cards. BCC Corporate issues Visa and
MasterCard credit cards, while American Express is issued by Alpha Card
and Diners Club directly. BNP Paribas Fortis issues the American Express
Blue credit card which targets individuals and small companies.
- MasterCard posted more dynamic growth than Visa over
the review period due to its close collaboration with retail chains.
American Express and Diners Club also saw their shares reduced towards the
end of the review period as a result of the rise of Visa and MasterCard
but retain a strong base among high-income groups and larger companies.
- Merchant support programmes increased during the
recession at the end of the review period, aiming to better promote the
benefits of credit cards at POS locations. According to Atos Worldline,
customers tend to spend €17 more on average in stores where credit card
signage and literature are prominently displayed. Issuers also used lower
APR rates and zero card charges to attract new clients. Annual charges
range widely, from €170 for Dexia MasterCard Platinum and €185 for Fintro
American Express Gold to less than €20 for KBC Pinto Visa.
- Co-branded cards are more frequent among credit cards
than among charge cards. These cards’ main attraction is special retailer
discounts and bonus points, which can be transformed into money, air miles
and other incentives. Cetelem’s Aurora MasterCard is the most widely used
co-branded credit card and is issued by a number of leading retail chains.
Other examples include MasterCard Touring with the Automobile Association
and MasterCard Base for mobile operators, with both being issued by ICS.
According to card companies, co-branded credit cards are used more often
than standard credit cards and are therefore more profitable for both
issuers and card companies.
- Around 63% of commercial credit cards were business or
corporate cards in 2009, 26% were fleet cards and the rest are purchasing
cards. Business cards grew faster towards the end of the review period,
driven by widening penetration among small and mid-sized companies. These
companies use business cards for small business purchases, the payment of
invoices and entertainment. Corporate cards are meanwhile designed for
companies with bigger travel requirements. Fleet cards are typically used
by medium-large companies for petrol and related purchases. Among new
products in commercial credit cards towards the end of the review period
was the ING Car Lease Fuel Pass. This is a chip and pin card offering
access to all leading petrol station networks in Belgium.
- 2009 and 2010 were challenging years for Belgian banks,
which came under pressure to cut costs, reduce risks and to improve
profitability. These pressures slowed down banks’ new product development
and innovation, with issuers instead focusing primarily on promoting
credit cards at POS locations and offering attractive terms to new
clients.
PROSPECTS
- Growth in personal credit cards is expected to be
driven by low interest rates, with these likely to remain unchanged during
2010 and into 2011. Personal credit card volume is expected to increase by
40% to around 1.1 million cards by 2015. These cards will continue to be
primarily used to finance more expensive personal and household purchases,
holidays and leisure/entertainment.
- The low penetration of credit cards among small and
mid-sized companies will meanwhile offer the opportunity for stronger
growth in commercial credit cards. The card volume of commercial credit
cards is thus expected to increase by 52% to 628,000 cards by 2015. Growth
will also be driven by the leading banks focusing marketing on this area
as they seek to broaden the use of such cards.
- E-commerce is expected to emerge as a key driver of
usage in both personal and commercial credit cards during the forecast
period. Belgian e-commerce is underdeveloped and is expected to see
dynamic growth during the forecast period, growing faster than retailing
as a whole. E-commerce is expected to become increasingly significant
because it represents a cheaper source of goods and services for consumers
than conventional stores along with offering a wider range of products.
- The forecast period may see the emergence of
multifunctional debit/credit cards in line with trends in other EU
countries. The leading operators such as Visa and MasterCard will continue
to develop this area through co-branding partnerships with retail
partners. Card development will focus on detailed target consumer
segmentation and on innovation in terms of benefit or reward packages.
- There will continue to be strong competition between
the leading operators during the forecast period. As players fight for
share, premium reward programmes are expected to be extended to
mass-market cards targeting medium-spending customers. Consequently, by
the end of the forecast period the majority of cards are likely to offer
full insurance packages and other benefits previously reserved for premium
cards.
- The new law on Consumer Lending will oblige card
issuers to follow strict vetting and administrative procedures during the
forecast period, with these aimed at protecting consumer rights and
providing clear and unambiguous information to card applicants. These
measures will be further strengthened through the new EU Directive on
Consumer Credit, with this due to be implemented in 2011.
·
Contact
Mahasagar Publications by posting your query to mahasagarpublications@gmail.com
for dissertation writing help.